There’s disappointment, and then there’s despair, and a vivid example of the latter came in the unlikely form of an April review on the Annie’s Homegrown website for its boxed Macaroni and Classic Cheddar, which has a new recipe that the package proclaims is “Now Cheesier!” “I’ve been eating this mac and cheese since I was literally 2 years old,” the one-star review began. “To say I’m devastated over the recipe change is an understatement. It tastes NOTHING like it used to. I’m never buying again unless you change the recipe back.” General Mills, which purchased Annie’s in 2014, announced the new recipe for some of the brand’s mac-and-cheese products in September, calling it a “delightful upgrade” that has “even more ooey gooey real cheese” in a press release. But many Annie’s customers disagree, and with the exception of incentivized positive reviews it imported from the Influenster.com website, many recent reviews on its website have been negative. “‘Now cheesier’ is extremely disappointing :(” stated an April one-star review from a woman who said she’d been eating the product “exclusively for 22 years” but now found the sauce to have “significantly less flavor” and wouldn’t be purchasing it again unless they “bring back the old recipe.” A recent post on Mouse Print, a consumer advocacy website, compared the old and new ingredient lists for the products and concluded that Annie’s is engaging in “skimpflation,” which refers to the reformulation of products with cheaper ingredients. The post concluded the new “ingredients don’t exactly shout new and improved.” Even though cheese is high in protein and calcium, it turns out the “Now Cheesier” recipe has 22.3% less of both protein (9 grams, previously 11) and calcium (90 milligrams, previously 110). That nutritional shift appears to come from a change in the recipe that General Mills did not highlight in its press release. Keep reading here.—AAN |