Fall deals pull demand from Black Friday, but it’s still a big day for retailers
As consumers shop earlier and with more intention, retailers face both opportunity and challenges to meet the demand.
• 4 min read
When it comes to holiday shopping, it’s not just about Black Friday weekend anymore. Shoppers are taking advantage of promotional events throughout the fall—and in some cases buying gifts over the summer months—according to experts.
“One in 4 consumers actually said that they were going to shop for the holiday during those back-to-school promotional events,” Brian McCarthy, principal at Deloitte, told Retail Brew.
More recent data backs this up: A new study from Deloitte found that 28% of shoppers would exhaust their holiday budgets by the end of October, up from 24% in 2025, while a survey from Bank of America found that just 17% of Americans will do most of their shopping on Black Friday, down from 25% in 2025.
The elephant in the room is Amazon’s October Prime Days, which a report from Adobe Analytics said “has changed the shape of the holiday shopping season, pushing US retailers to manage promotions and inventory effectively to capture an additional pre-season spike in shopping interest.”
But don’t count Black Friday out. As shoppers pull their spending forward, it’s still all about the promotional events, and any kind of deal is going to be a draw for cautious consumers, according to McCarthy.
“It’s less about the spend moving away from Black Friday/Cyber Monday, and it’s more all the days in between these promotional events must be a bit softer,” he said.
The upside for retailers is that spending is occurring in these more concentrated buckets, which “helps brands and retailers plan out and control inventory,” McCarthy added, giving them the confidence to buy sufficient volumes of product.
However, companies should be wary about how they handle replenishment, Johannes Panzer, head of global e-commerce at Descartes, a logistics planning platform, told Retail Brew. “Strong October sales don’t necessarily mean those same products will see similar demand on Black Friday,” he wrote in an email. “Sellers need to look closely at their own sales data before making replenishment decisions.”
Retail Brew delivers the latest retail industry news and insights surrounding marketing, DTC, and e-commerce to keep leaders and decision-makers up to date.
By subscribing, you accept our Terms & Privacy Policy.
This speaks to another trend in how consumers are planning out their holiday shopping: They have done their research and are less susceptible to the element of surprise.
“I think Black Friday historically was almost a surprise, and people would be queuing up in front of a store hours before opening and rushing in to find what was on sale,” Kelly Askew, global retail industry lead at Accenture, said. What they are doing is planning out their purchases in advance, and then choosing the best moment to hit the buy button, he said: “Customers have done their research. They’ve done their planning. They’ve probably chosen what they want to buy, but then they’re deciding based upon whether the deal is acceptable.”
Askew also sees this as an opportunity for retailers to have “a lot less frenzy in their merchant organization or in their finance department.” As more volume is pulled forward, retailers can get a “little more predictability and smooth out that demand across the year,” he said.
As for sealing the deal come Black Friday, the level of discount could be the crucial variable.
“Retailers are going to need to offer some pretty decent discounts to get the traffic in there, and they’re going to have to offer an array of products at different price points to keep up with the demand,” Christine Short, head of research at Wall Street Horizon, said.
The consumer is getting savvier in this area as well. AI has made it easier to look at a product’s price over the past 18 months, Askew said, which presents another opportunity for retailers to “get a little bit more of a planful interaction with the consumer earlier by getting the promotions out in a more orderly way.”
About the author
Alex Vuocolo
Alex covers big box chains, discounters, and specialty retailers with a focus on store operations, supply chains, and retail economics.
Retail Brew delivers the latest retail industry news and insights surrounding marketing, DTC, and e-commerce to keep leaders and decision-makers up to date.
By subscribing, you accept our Terms & Privacy Policy.